How would you apply the following plays in the statistics?
#1. B1 tackles A1 in the backfield for a loss of 2.
A. B1 is rewarded 1 Tackle AND 1 TFL
B. B1 is rewarded 1 TFL, 0 Tackles
(there are leagues where both answers are true)
#2. B1 tackles (sacks) quarterback A1, while A1 attempts a forward pass behind the line of scrimmage.
A. B1 is rewarded 0 Tackle, 0 TFL, and 1 sack
B. B1 is rewarded 1 Tackle, 1 Sack, 0 TFL
C. B1 is rewarded 1 Tackle, 1 Sack, 1 TFL
#3. B1 sacks A1 and forces a fumble on the play, recovered by A2 who is called down ion the backfield.
A. B1 is rewarded a Forced Fumble, and no sack
B. B1 is rewarded 1 FF, and 1 Sack
C. B1 is rewarded 1 FF, 1 Sack, 1 Tackle
So far, if I believe I have spotted every one of these scenarios and outcomes in the stat column. Not a big deal because ultimately the final score is the only important stat, but I feel that we should try to be uniform.
-- Edited by Cpt Crunch on Wednesday 9th of April 2014 08:08:40 AM
Based on my experience reading prior NCAA guidelines, and running the Matadors. I am sure many can argue different ways of doing this. The answers to your scenarios:
#1 - (A) Player should get credit for 1 tackle plus 1 TFL #2 - (C) Player should get credit for 1 tackle, 1 TFL and 1 sack. #3 - (C) Player should get credit for 1 tackle, 1 TFL and 1 FF
According to the to stat tracking sheets available from hosted sports a sack counts as a sack, a tackle for a loss and a tackle. Tackles for a loss are counted as a tfl and a tackle. The best way to read it is player 1 got 6 tackles, 3 of them were for a loss and one was a sack. So his stats read 6tackles, 4tfl and one sack.
No wonder why we end up with 60 tackles on 40 plays from scrimmage. Sorry my Bulldawg brothers I screwed you guy's out of many tackles throughout the years. It was either a sack, tackle for loss, or a tackle, only one per play.
@Jake Sheen - me too! That's the way it should be! 1 per play. Make it uniform. All this "extra credit" crap skews everything. If you get a sack, it is a sack. Not a bloody tfl, tackle and sack! Just a sack.
Unitl there is a decision made, I will continue to do it as hosted sports stat tracker form suggests. Sorry but that keeps it uniform all the way around. It doesn't skew the results that much either way. Take Shane Thomas for example, add in his totals from the final game and his 12 tackles there and he still leads the league in tackles. But if the League sets down guidelines on how they want stats done then we will track them that way.