I hope we can move up next year and depending on how things go I can see them moving either the oilers or the snow devils up too. Then you have 2 potential add ins to the league with the Wyoming outlaws and the Utah unique. And I heard rumors that the 9 man Idaho Phoenix wanna apply. Then you have the matadors and generals who forfeited their playoff games and sounds like instead of the bottom 2 teams going down to AA, the matadors and generals would move down. It will be interesting to see how the league deals with that situation. So then if you have the oilers move up, and the matadors and the generals move down. And add the unique and the outlaws. You get the same amount of teams in AAA and 12 teams in AA. And that's if no one folds.
Trying to figure this out now is like a teenager hoping he's going to get lucky on the first date before he's even asked the girl out....
If a team folds then that throws a wrench into the whole works then you throw in two new teams and that's a couple of more wrenches of where to place them.
Correct me if I'm wrong but it was decided that the winning team moves up with the lowest team in their region moving down. That would be the Vipers moving up and the Shock (based on prior to the post-season) moving down but I find it very possible that the Shock will have a very good laugh in regards to that and be very content with staying in AAA.
So lets say the Unique are accepted then they could replace the Vipers in AA and if the Snow Devils move up then the Wyoming team could replace them. IMO this is the best option because anything under 8 teams in the AA would create schedule/travel issues.
I don't think forfeiting your playoff spot should be a reason to move down to AA, if so then that will happen more often and we all know that is bad news.
18 teams in AAA and 9 teams in AA (If the Phoenix do apply and are accepted) would be an awesome arrangement for everyone if you ask me.
-- Edited by UPY77 on Thursday 3rd of July 2014 01:47:10 PM
It is almost impossible to predict what will happen but its fun trying. It looks like it just might turn into a bit of a mess. Wondering how that meeting will go lol.
Even though we were at the bottom of the league this year, I have spoken to Brad and stated that the Bullets have no interest in moving down, we want to play and compete in the AAA. We got knocked down but we always got up for the next play. See you all in January.
There was no intent to disrespect you there Kyto, everything I see and hear from the Shock show how great of an organization you have and for that, I have much respect for you and the Shock. You guys have always been a force to be reckoned with and you showed that all season. I think that the way the league structure is set up now strengthens the fact that the AA is for teams to get better and to move up to the AAA and be competitive.
-- Edited by UPY77 on Thursday 3rd of July 2014 10:54:29 PM
Rumor has it that both the Guardians, Digger's and the Anarchy will be folding in the offseason. If that's the case, that will make Idaho an even bigger laughing stock then it already is. How can every other state in this league produce quality new teams except for Idaho?? Cough cough Guardians & Lancer's???? Really is that the kind of teams we want added into our growing league??
Idaho Phoenix I doubt will get voted in. They already are a joke. The league is getting bigger and bigger and Idaho is falling farther and farther behind in competing.
-- Edited by dozer60 on Friday 4th of July 2014 02:22:58 AM
__________________
“Anyone who's just driven 90 yards against huge men trying to kill them has earned the right to do Jazz hands. ” ― Craig Ferguson
So I know this is all speculation, but I have given the 2015 AA layout some thought. Now I know there are rumors of teams folding, and rumors of an "All Idaho league" (although I think this is just the product of some GM's mistrust of the league fee and not paying attention to the budget at the league meeting) and some new teams trying to join. But for the purposes of this thread lets assume a few things:
1. No teams are folding
2. Both Uintah Basin and Davis move up to the AAA
3. Great Falls and Magic Valley move down to the AA
4. Wyoming Outlaws put together and make the league.
5. No other teams are inducted at the AA level.
Again this is just speculation
You would take the 9 teams in the AA and break them into 3 divisions to limit travel. Each team would then in turn play home and home in there division and two teams from the other two division making up the 8 game schedule.
West Division: Gem State Guardians, Idaho Lancers and Magic Valley Bulldawgs. Longest travel distant for a division game is 160 miles.
North Division: Idaho Mustangs, Gallatin Valley Snow Devils, and Great Falls Gladiators. Longest travel distance for a division game is 360 miles. (i know this is long but Great Falls is a long ways from anyone else.
South Division: Elko Warriors, Mini Cassia Diggers, and Wyoming Outlaws. Longest travel distance for a division game is 315 miles.
This would increase the competition in the AA, allowing the teams in the AA to minimize there travel and help these teams to build a product that will grow there teams so they can be competitive in the AAA. However, this is all based on the above conditions being met. If the snow Devils decide to move up or the Oilers decide not to this will just throw a big wrench in the entire process.
But that is my piece for now. Looking at the league as a whole we know the Gladiators will move down to try and save there product. The Vipers will move up because that is the rule. Shock, Bulldogs and Gladiators all fit the profile to move down but we know the Shock won't and I applaud Kyto for taking that stand. Generals and Matadors don't qualify to move down because of there record (the forfeit while embarrassing to the league has no bearing on the league standings).
this is no respect to any team or their talent level.....im thinking of the league. i apologize in advance if anyone is offended. the point of the aa / aaa split is to allow lesser teams to be competitive in their division.....not to prove a point. as a board, we have to make decisions based on the overall league. are the Vipers or Oilers or SnowDevils better than the teams we are moving down? if not, we arent accomplishing our goal to make the aaa the best of the best. we will still have blowout games in aaa. a good aa team does not always make a competitve team. we have to keep that in kind and understand it. would those teams fair any better than the ones we would be dropping down? would you rather have a first year aaa Vipers team or a second year Bulldawgs team? after a year in aaa, the Cobras know what to build on and recruit for next year. it probably takes a year just to understand that. i would hate to have the Cobras moved down and then dominate aa only to have to move back up and start all over. the bulldawgs, gladiators, bullets, ducks and FOR SURE shock would probably beat any team in the current aa. in my opinion, if any of those teams drop, they win the aa championship next year. i say we leave it as it is for another year, let the new teams come in as aa teams and build on the parity of that division. 10 teams or 11 teams or whatever.....figure it out. it will also offset any teams folding. there was enough parity that realistically any of the top 4 out of the 8 teams could have won the championship. thats a great setup. Vipers won the championship but werent dominant in aa. voting was probably 50/50. i think that is what we are striving for. if a team isnt sandbagging in aa than let them stay. the 2014 vipers or oilers or snowdevils are not the 2013 generals. let the bulldawgs, gladiators and bullets recover from a down season and stay put in aaa another year. lets get some stability in the new structure before we overhaul the whole thing. let the Vipers try to repeat and defend their title. if the Vipers, Devils and Oilers leave, other than the Mustangs you are dealing with nothing but new, rebuilding or starter teams less than 3 years in the league. warriors, lancers, guardians, diggers and mustangs with any new team coming in. is that what you want in aa? i also think we should only accept teams in the league if a team folds for the next couple years. there are too many moving parts right now to be a srable league. i think the plans for the offseason should be.....
aaa playoff seeding
league sponsorship
all star game/championship game dates and locations
team/staff/division respect of each other and league perception
website/forum
adherence/enforcement of constitution/rules
i have no problems with you moving up.i think you missed my point.exchanging last team for first team may not be the best formula because it lacks consistency in teams trying to be aaa ready.if the Vipers move up and lose every game in 2015 and the Bulldawgs win the aa after moving down in 2015, have we gained anything as a league? the point should be and i think is to move teams up that are going to add parity to the aaa and make more parity for aa.i think we need teams to stay in aaa a couple years and BUILD for aaa rather than survive one season and then move back.im not all saying that will happen to the Vipers.im just throwing it out there.exchanging a team that didnt make the playoffs with another team that didnt make the playoffs doesnt add anything to the league or the structure.i just think maybe we should change the constitution to keep a structure for at least 2 years unless a team lobbies to go down just to give a team one year to see it and one year to improve on it.i hope that makes sense.even if the teams move up i think this is something to consider moving forward.
Jaye u still pickin against us lol...we handled everyone that was thrown at us in AA n won the ship in convincing matter if the Cobras are good enough to move up after last year we are definitely good enough after this year...This isn't the same Viper team u beat 2 years ago...n our teams can play whenever u are ready so we can prove u wrong
Vipers#13
slow down mr.mak.....i think youre missing the point.....youre making it a Vipers or Cobras thing.....i speak RMFL and not in regards to any particular team.not even my own team.....even if i use examples.read the message and not the specifics.
#1 i dont beat my chest about my squad.im not that guy.i saw you guys play a couple times...you got some ballers.....#2, #11, some of your linemen stood out as athletes but dont be the 2011 / 2012 gladiators and get ahead of yourselves.congrats on the wins.enjoy it.my hats off to you guys....thats enough said on the challenge.it was entertaining though.
#2 sometimes its hard to fix or stabilize something when you constantly have moving parts.we bave a couple major issues in the playoff seeding and scheduling.lets create a stable structure and formula before we continuously change.lets make sure we have a solid formula for a year or two prior to switching things up again.no team in aa was the 2013 generals and blew over every team they faced.the good thing was that teams won that werent expected to.thats what parity is.the generals staying down in 2013 or the gladiators who smashed eveyone in their path were clearly better than at least 2 or 3 teams in aaa.i dont think that is the case this year.moving teams up should be to improve the aaa.if its not than we are not accomplishing our goal.
#3 my point is to leave it as it is.the top 4 teams in aa are close enough in talent to still have parity and fair competition.while the other teams in aa have another year to catch up.the bottom 4 aaa teams can stay where they are and rebuild after what simply appeared to be a year with some unforeseen problems.i think any of those teams runs through aa in dominant fashion.especially if Vipers, Devils and/or Oilers move up.in the meantime, we can use the same teams and structure to create a consistent structure for years to come.you cannot do that when the landscape keeps changing.
-- Edited by GORILLA20 on Sunday 6th of July 2014 09:02:43 AM
Dozer60 i am curious what you consider quality teams are. The lancers went from 0-8 and getting killed every game too 4-4 and competing with every team. You world think that is a huge improvement and that would have the type of team you would want joining the league. Not every single New team is going to be a top contender their very first year.
For what it's worth, here are a couple of thoughts AT THIS POINT (as has been stated, a lot will change in the next 6 months)...
Vipers should and will move up. I do believe the Utah Unique will petition RMFL acceptance for next year. I'm not so sure about the Outlaws or the Phoenix (I'm skeptical of the Phoenix, but the Sting have a game scheduled with them on July 19th, so I'll reserve judgement until after that game). The Outlaws know what it takes to be in the RMFL and won't apply unless they're fairly certain they've got their ducks in a row to get accepted (enough players, a home field with locker rooms and a scoreboard, etc.). I also wouldn't be surprised if we get another team from the 9 man Utah Tackle Football League (where the Unique played this past year), but I could be wrong. We have already received some interest from other areas for next year (Vegas, Helena, etc.) but that is not new and I'm not counting on any of those teams yet.
At this point, I haven't heard of any teams folding or asking to move down; but if historical averages hold true, we could have one or two teams not come back. If we look at the AAA teams with the lowest records for 2014, I think a case could be made for keeping each of them AAA; but, if any of them WANTED to move down to AA, that could be an option. As I've said multiple times before, one of the best things about the current structure is that we have more flexibility than we have in years past to not only move teams up and down but accept new teams.
Personally (and I think anyone that has been around the league longer than 1 year would agree), I just love to see Vipers guys saying they are excited to move up and other teams fighting about not moving down. That is a 180 degree paradigm shift from the past several years of teams fighting to stay AA and not wanting to move up. We're doing something right, just need to keep getting better every year.
Let the Vipers go AAA it will be nice to see how they handle the big 4. Great falls tried it once and lost by 35 plus points on average lol and I know viper 54 is still on his wining high but when reality hits he gonna wish they played gem state and the mini cassia again for those big blowout wins
A winning high? Go back and look at the forums before the season. I was saying I wanted to move up to AAA before it even started. Look at the jamboree post. I said it before the season and I'm saying it now. And why would I wish to beat teams by 71 points? I would rather play against better competition and better myself rather then waste my Saturdays by beating teams that bad.
Fact no one wants to think about....... the 2014 AA teams during the 2013 season had a combined regular season record of 16-64 (.250). The Oilers where the only 2014 AA team to finish the 2013 regular season with a winning.record.
It will be interesting. Its a complete different level. I know the general's are not the same team as last year but in 2013 that team was unstoppable. And from what it looks like there are even better teams in Utah.
Like I said how do u know how you will do unless u are thrown into the fire...why does it matter how we handle THE BIG 4...it's football u win u lose but in the the end we all play to for the competition...if u don't play the best then why even play...2013 AA records show's that teams are getting better...just look at the records for this year as most of all those teams have vastly improved and I imagine will only get better...I know as far as The Vipers go we aren't even the same team as last year we have a good nucleus of good new players and it showed going from 1-7 to AA Champs...u can only see how u will do if u try...either way I'm ready for any challenge thrown my way as is my entire team
VIPERS#13
Like I said how do u know how you will do unless u are thrown into the fire...why does it matter how we handle THE BIG 4...it's football u win u lose but in the the end we all play to for the competition...if u don't play the best then why even play...2013 AA records show's that teams are getting better...just look at the records for this year as most of all those teams have vastly improved and I imagine will only get better...I know as far as The Vipers go we aren't even the same team as last year we have a good nucleus of good new players and it showed going from 1-7 to AA Champs...u can only see how u will do if u try...either way I'm ready for any challenge thrown my way as is my entire team
VIPERS#13
Glad to hear the Vipers are a different team then they use to be. It will be more then fun playing you guys next year...I am just hoping my old ass can still lace up the boots and play another season. lmao....
__________________
Any incorrect grammar, spelling, or inproper use of verbiage, shall be blamed on my iPhone not me!
Gladiators are staying AAA.....We had rough season but it was do to some last minute changes. It was a player ran team and even though we only played 16-21 players we never forfeited any game. We are already building for next season and will be well prepared.
I would really like to know where these rumors keep coming that the Guardians are folding because we have no plans of folding anytime soon
Let's start this drama back up shall we? I'm going to guess it's coming from the fact that you have won 1 game in how many years? I'm sure anyone in Idaho, or even the RMFL, will be surprised if the guardians can have a reasonable roster next year.
Now that's just devils advocate right there. At least the guardians finished the season and didn't forfeit their last game of the season. *cough cough*
I've heard the ICFL buzzards are on prowl so watch out guardians, word is they're still trying to get the Lancers to move to 9 man. Hell, they're probably taking to the generals and matadors too!!
Do the Guardians even know what 9 man football consists of?? Traveling is fun and all but if the Guardians do stay in the RMFL will the be even close to competitive in 2015??
who cares? every team in the league is viable. competitive or not. the league is and should be about more than that. Guardians...best of luck to you...strap em up and the league will see you boys in 2015. holla.
Guardians did not score a single point this season. This was the worst season for them yet with the easiest schedule yet. They actually got worse this year. I will say they have not forfieted yet and that's a surprise. But i will say they need a new person running that offence and heck a new guy running that defence. Probably some of the worst coaching in the league.
7-499 first year points against 3 AAA teams now.
0-403 third year against all bottom of the AA last year.
In my mind that's the worst season yet for the guardians.i hope the guardians the best but it's not looking very well. They need a major over haul. I would say with trying to get some better coaches and get some one that can recruit.
explorers.....i'm not really understanding your point. No "offence".....see what i did there.....but I'm not sure why you care so much. Are you trying to take over the team and over haul it?
-- Edited by GORILLA20 on Wednesday 23rd of July 2014 12:09:28 PM